Deforest Buckner Is Back: 49ers Bring Home a Former Top-10 Pick

Coming off a loss in Atlanta, the 49ers made a move at the trade deadline that Bay Area fans have wanted for years. On Tuesday, San Francisco acquired defensive tackle DeForest Buckner from the Indianapolis Colts for a 2027 fourth-round pick.

For a 6-1 team that suddenly has a hole up front, the price is small. Buckner is a three-time Pro Bowler, and he returns to the franchise that drafted him.

A Wrong Righted

The 49ers took Buckner with the No. 7 overall pick in 2016, and he spent his first four seasons in the Bay. After the 2019 Super Bowl run, San Francisco sent him to Indianapolis for a first-round pick rather than pay him a big extension. John Lynch has since called that the toughest call he has made as general manager. Seven years later, he has the player back.

Why It Makes Sense Now

The defensive line has been one of the biggest problems on this team. Alfred Collins, C.J. West and James Thompson Jr. have all been out with injuries at tackle, and Nick Bosa has been dealing with a calf issue. The result is a pass rush that doesn’t work unless the coaching staff sends extra bodies. With four or fewer rushers, San Francisco’s pressure rate is 23%, second-worst in the league.

The Falcons game showed how bad it has gotten. The Niners pressured Michael Penix Jr. on only three of his 34 dropbacks.

Buckner has four sacks this season, more than anyone on the 49ers, and he’ll slot in next to Osa Odighizuwa on the interior. He is also one of just four players since 2016 with at least 75 sacks and 25 batted passes, along with T.J. Watt, Cameron Jordan and Chris Jones. He knocks down passes as well as sacking the quarterback, and a defense that needs help up the middle needs both.

The Colts’ Side

Buckner is 32, and his contract expires after the season. Indianapolis was heading toward a rebuild, with a three-game losing streak and a front office that has changed. The Colts also traded guard Quenton Nelson to Seattle on the same day. If Buckner had walked in free agency, the best compensatory pick Indianapolis could have gotten was a fifth-rounder in 2028. A 2027 fourth is a better return.

A Homecoming Trend

Buckner joins Deebo Samuel and Dre Greenlaw as former Niners who have come back to the Bay in the last year or so. All three are back for the same reason: San Francisco looks like a team that can win a championship, and this front office is willing to spend to make it happen.

What’s Next

Buckner won’t fix everything. The injuries won’t go away overnight, and one player can’t cover for several. But he gives this defense a veteran who can win inside, and the Niners have lacked one all season. If Bosa gets healthy and the other tackles return, this line could look completely different by December.

Previous
Previous

The 49ers Would Be Foolish Not to Go All In on a Wide Receiver

Next
Next

Seahawks win super bowl 60 at levis staduim